- The Daily Step 1 Newsletter
- Posts
- 🔍 Which of the following caused the Patient's Pleural Effusion?
🔍 Which of the following caused the Patient's Pleural Effusion?
Dr. Shoaib Ahmad Baig
December 20, 2024
🔍 Question
A 64-year-old female presents to the emergency department with a 4-day history of difficulty breathing and a cough producing sputum. Her past medical history includes polymyalgia rheumatica, managed with a low-dose corticosteroid. On physical examination, percussion reveals dullness, and auscultation shows reduced breath sounds over the right lower lung region. The abdominal exam is unremarkable. A chest X-ray demonstrates a parenchymal opacity and a moderate pleural effusion in the right lower lobe. Thoracentesis is performed, yielding blood-tinged fluid. Laboratory results for pleural fluid and serum analysis are as follows:
Parameter | Pleural Fluid | Serum |
|---|---|---|
Total Protein | 4.5 g/dL | 6.5 g/dL |
Lactate Dehydrogenase | 40 U/L | 60 U/L |
Based on these findings, what is the most likely mechanism contributing to the development of this patient’s pleural effusion?
• A. Low plasma oncotic pressure
• B. Impaired lymphatic drainage from the thorax
• C. Elevated intraabdominal hydrostatic pressure
• D. Increased negative pressure within the pleural cavity
• E. Enhanced vascular permeability in the pleura
• F. Increased hydrostatic pressure in the thorax
Correct Answer 🎯: Increased Pleural Vascular Permeability 🧠
⚙️
Infection/Inflammation in Lung → Pneumonia
⬇
Inflammatory Cytokines ↑ (e.g., IL-1, TNF-α) 🧠
⬇
Capillary Permeability ↑ in Pleural Vasculature
⬇
Leakage of Protein-rich Fluid into Pleural Space 🧠
⬇
Pleural Fluid Total Protein ↑ (Exudate)
⬇
↓ Oncotic Pressure Difference Across Capillary Membrane
⬇
Fluid Accumulation → Pleural Effusion
How To Approach this Question? 🏗️
🧠 Step 1: Light’s Criteria (Exudate vs Transudate)
Logic (Key 🔍): Compare pleural fluid and serum protein/LDH ratios to determine the type of effusion.
Criteria | Exudate 🧠 | Transudate |
|---|---|---|
Pleural Protein / Serum Protein > 0.5 | Yes → Protein-rich exudate ↑ ⚙️ | No → Protein-poor transudate ⬇ |
Pleural LDH / Serum LDH > 0.6 | Typically ↑ LDH in exudates ⚙️ | Normal or slightly ⬇ LDH |
⚙️ Step 2: Mechanisms for Pleural Effusion
The pathophysiology always involves fluid accumulation → But how does this occur?
Mechanism ⚙ | Explanation 🧠 | Examples |
|---|---|---|
↑ Vascular Permeability ⚙️ | Capillary leak → Proteins escape 🧠 | Pneumonia, malignancy |
↓ Oncotic Pressure ⬇ | ↓ Plasma albumin → Water follows ⚖️ | Liver failure, nephrotic syndrome |
↑ Hydrostatic Pressure ↑ | ↑ Pressure → Fluid leaks into pleura 🧠 | Heart failure, volume overload |
↓ Lymphatic Drainage ⚙️ | Blocked flow → Fluid buildup 🧠 | Malignancy, chylothorax |
Key Insight 🧠 :
• Use Light’s Criteria to differentiate exudates vs transudates 🧠
• Always reason through mechanisms:
• ⚙️Capillary permeability ↑ → Exudate
• ⚖️ Contrast with transudates → ↓ oncotic or ↑ hydrostatic pressure
⚖️ Explanation of Other Differentials
Differential ⚖️ | Likely Cause ⚙️ | Why Incorrect? 🔴 |
|---|---|---|
↓ Oncotic Pressure ⬇ | Liver failure, nephrotic syndrome | Pleural protein is high ↑ |
↑ Hydrostatic Pressure ↑ | Heart failure, volume overload | Transudates → Low protein ⬇ |
↓ Lymphatic Drainage | Malignancy, chylothorax | No chylous (milky) fluid here |
↑ Vascular Permeability | Pneumonia (Correct) 🧠 | Protein-rich exudate present ↑ |
Explains Option (A)and (E). Source: NEJM
📝 Flashcards
Stay Hungry, Stay Curious!
Your Brother In This Struggle
Dr. Shoaib Ahmad
ps…Just a heads up!
This is just an excerpt from a high-yield e-book "Excel USMLE Step 1: Respiratory System" that we are launching next month InshaAllah.
With this e-book, you’ll be able to Excel any USMLE Step 1 question on respiratory section without fear of getting a wrong answer in just 1 week using visual charts and flashcards.
This e-book will feature:
High-yield USMLE Step 1 questions on the respiratory system.
Conceptual clarity for every question to solidify your understanding.
Problem-solving strategies to enhance your test-taking skills.
Flashcards for each question to reinforce learning.
You can pre-order now.
Future editions covering other systems will follow shortly.
Each e-book in the series is priced individually.
Special Offer:
61% off during the pre-order period.
Money-back guarantee if you’re not satisfied—no questions asked!