Which finding is most likely in his lower lung lobes?

πŸ” Question of the Day

Patient Profile:

β€’ Age: 35-year-old man

β€’ Chief Complaint: Worsening shortness of breath

History of Present Illness:

β€’ Timeline: Worsening shortness of breath over the past 18 months. Initially noticed during hiking, now occurs even with walking.

β€’ Associated Symptoms: Occasional mild wheezing and sputum production.

β€’ Medical History: No significant past illnesses.

β€’ Lifestyle Factors: Smokes 0.5 packs/day for 5 years.

 Family History: Father died young from lung and liver disease

Pulmonary Function Tests (PFTs):

β€’ FEV1: Decreased

β€’ FVC: Decreased

β€’ FEV1/FVC ratio: Reduced

Which of the following findings is most likely in the lower lung lobes of this patient?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Correct Answer 🎯: D. Panacinar Emphysema

βš™οΈ

Genetic Mutation in SERPINA1 Gene (AAT deficiency)

⬇

Reduced AAT production in the liver

⬇

⬇ Inhibition of neutrophil elastase in the lungs (protease-antiprotease imbalance)

⬇

Elastase activity ↑ in alveolar walls

⬇

Progressive destruction of alveoli (affects lower lobes predominantly)

⬇

Panacinar emphysema develops (uniform involvement of entire acinus)

⬇

↓ Elastic recoil of lungs

⬇

Air trapping and hyperinflation

⬇

↓ FEV1/FVC ratio (obstructive pattern on spirometry)

⬇

Symptoms: Progressive dyspnea, wheezing, sputum production

Symptoms Explained πŸ”§

Progressive Dyspnea

βš™ Mechanism:

Smoking + AAT deficiency β†’ ⬇ AAT β†’ Unopposed neutrophil elastase activity

⬇

Alveolar elastin degradation β†’ Loss of elastic recoil β†’ Air trapping

⬇

Hyperinflation β†’ Increased work of breathing β†’ Dyspnea

Mild Wheezing

βš™ Mechanism:

Elastin breakdown β†’ Small airway collapse during expiration β†’ Airflow obstruction

⬇

Turbulent airflow in airways β†’ Wheezing

Sputum Production

βš™ Mechanism:

Smoking β†’ Airway irritation and inflammation

⬇

Goblet cell hyperplasia β†’ Increased mucus production β†’ Sputum

Progression from Hikes to Walking

βš™ Mechanism:

⬆ Destruction of alveolar walls β†’ Loss of surface area for gas exchange

⬇

⬇ Pulmonary compliance β†’ Further increase in breathing effort

⬇

Symptoms worsen from exertion to daily activities

How To Approach this Question? πŸ—οΈ

Patient Symptoms

β€’ Progressive dyspnea + mild wheezing & sputum production

⬇

πŸ” Initial Diagnostic Clue: Spirometry Findings

β€’ β¬‡ FEV1, ⬇ FVC, ⬇ FEV1/FVC ratio (Obstructive pattern)

⬇

βš– Compare Differentials Using Key Clues:

β€’ Young age + family history of lung & liver disease β†’ 🧠 Suggests AAT deficiency.

β€’ Lower lobe involvement β†’ 🧠 Consistent with panacinar emphysema (AAT deficiency).

⬇

Primary Diagnosis: Panacinar Emphysema (AAT Deficiency)

βš™ Mechanism:

β€’ SERPINA1 mutation β†’ ⬇ AAT production β†’ ↑ elastase activity β†’ alveolar destruction.

⬇

Confirmatory Diagnostic Steps:

β€’ πŸ” Serum AAT levels β†’ ⬇ (confirm deficiency).

β€’ βš™ Genetic testing β†’ Identify SERPINA1 mutation.

βš–οΈ Explanation of Other Differentials

Differential βš–οΈ

Mechanism βš™οΈ

Why Incorrect? πŸ”΄

Panacinar Emphysema

🧠 AAT deficiency β†’ ⬇ inhibition of elastase β†’ ↑ alveolar destruction (entire acinus, lower lobes)

Most likely due to family history (father with lung & liver disease), young age, and smoking aggravating AAT deficiency.

Centriacinar Emphysema

🧠 Smoke β†’ ↑ oxidative stress β†’ localized inflammation β†’ destruction of respiratory bronchioles (upper lobes)

Unlikely as predominantly affects upper lobes; smoking history is mild and family history does not support this diagnosis.

Chronic Bronchitis

🧠 Smoke β†’ chronic airway inflammation β†’ ↑ mucus production β†’ obstruction

Spirometry supports obstruction but sputum production & wheezing are mild; no history of recurrent infections.

Bronchiectasis

βš™ Recurrent infections β†’ airway remodeling β†’ dilation

Unlikely as there’s no chronic infection, hemoptysis, or characteristic imaging findings.

Spontaneous Pneumothorax

βš™ Subpleural blebs rupture β†’ sudden dyspnea, pleuritic chest pain

No acute onset or pleuritic pain; symptoms are progressive.

πŸ“ Flashcards

Stay Hungry, Stay Curious!

Your Brother In This Struggle

Dr. Shoaib Ahmad

ps…Just a heads up!

This is just an excerpt from our high-yield Q bank "Excel USMLE Step1: Respiratory System" that we are launching next month InshaAllah.

With this Q-bank, you’ll be able to Excel any USMLE Step 1 question on respiratory section without fear of getting a wrong answer using our visual charts and flashcards.

This e-book will feature:

  • High-yield USMLE Step 1 questions on the respiratory system.

  • Conceptual clarity for every question to solidify your understanding.

  • Problem-solving strategies to enhance your test-taking skills.

  • Flashcards for each question to reinforce learning.

You can pre-order now.

Future editions covering other systems will follow shortly.

Each e-book in the series is priced individually.

Special Offer:

  • 61% off during the pre-order period.

Money-back guarantee if you’re not satisfiedβ€”no questions asked!