- The Daily Step 1 Newsletter
- Posts
- Which finding is most likely in his lower lung lobes?
Which finding is most likely in his lower lung lobes?
π Question of the Day
Patient Profile:
β’ Age: 35-year-old man
β’ Chief Complaint: Worsening shortness of breath
History of Present Illness:
β’ Timeline: Worsening shortness of breath over the past 18 months. Initially noticed during hiking, now occurs even with walking.
β’ Associated Symptoms: Occasional mild wheezing and sputum production.
β’ Medical History: No significant past illnesses.
β’ Lifestyle Factors: Smokes 0.5 packs/day for 5 years.
Family History: Father died young from lung and liver disease
Pulmonary Function Tests (PFTs):
β’ FEV1: Decreased
β’ FVC: Decreased
β’ FEV1/FVC ratio: Reduced
Which of the following findings is most likely in the lower lung lobes of this patient? |
Correct Answer π―: D. Panacinar Emphysema
βοΈ
Genetic Mutation in SERPINA1 Gene (AAT deficiency)
β¬
Reduced AAT production in the liver
β¬
β¬ Inhibition of neutrophil elastase in the lungs (protease-antiprotease imbalance)
β¬
Elastase activity β in alveolar walls
β¬
Progressive destruction of alveoli (affects lower lobes predominantly)
β¬
Panacinar emphysema develops (uniform involvement of entire acinus)
β¬
β Elastic recoil of lungs
β¬
Air trapping and hyperinflation
β¬
β FEV1/FVC ratio (obstructive pattern on spirometry)
β¬
Symptoms: Progressive dyspnea, wheezing, sputum production
Symptoms Explained π§
Progressive Dyspnea
β Mechanism:
Smoking + AAT deficiency β β¬ AAT β Unopposed neutrophil elastase activity
β¬
Alveolar elastin degradation β Loss of elastic recoil β Air trapping
β¬
Hyperinflation β Increased work of breathing β Dyspnea
Mild Wheezing
β Mechanism:
Elastin breakdown β Small airway collapse during expiration β Airflow obstruction
β¬
Turbulent airflow in airways β Wheezing
Sputum Production
β Mechanism:
Smoking β Airway irritation and inflammation
β¬
Goblet cell hyperplasia β Increased mucus production β Sputum
Progression from Hikes to Walking
β Mechanism:
β¬ Destruction of alveolar walls β Loss of surface area for gas exchange
β¬
β¬ Pulmonary compliance β Further increase in breathing effort
β¬
Symptoms worsen from exertion to daily activities
How To Approach this Question? ποΈ
Patient Symptoms
β’ Progressive dyspnea + mild wheezing & sputum production
β¬
π Initial Diagnostic Clue: Spirometry Findings
β’ β¬ FEV1, β¬ FVC, β¬ FEV1/FVC ratio (Obstructive pattern)
β¬
β Compare Differentials Using Key Clues:
β’ Young age + family history of lung & liver disease β π§ Suggests AAT deficiency.
β’ Lower lobe involvement β π§ Consistent with panacinar emphysema (AAT deficiency).
β¬
Primary Diagnosis: Panacinar Emphysema (AAT Deficiency)
β Mechanism:
β’ SERPINA1 mutation β β¬ AAT production β β elastase activity β alveolar destruction.
β¬
Confirmatory Diagnostic Steps:
β’ π Serum AAT levels β β¬ (confirm deficiency).
β’ β Genetic testing β Identify SERPINA1 mutation.
βοΈ Explanation of Other Differentials
Differential βοΈ | Mechanism βοΈ | Why Incorrect? π΄ |
---|---|---|
Panacinar Emphysema | π§ AAT deficiency β β¬ inhibition of elastase β β alveolar destruction (entire acinus, lower lobes) | Most likely due to family history (father with lung & liver disease), young age, and smoking aggravating AAT deficiency. |
Centriacinar Emphysema | π§ Smoke β β oxidative stress β localized inflammation β destruction of respiratory bronchioles (upper lobes) | Unlikely as predominantly affects upper lobes; smoking history is mild and family history does not support this diagnosis. |
Chronic Bronchitis | π§ Smoke β chronic airway inflammation β β mucus production β obstruction | Spirometry supports obstruction but sputum production & wheezing are mild; no history of recurrent infections. |
Bronchiectasis | β Recurrent infections β airway remodeling β dilation | Unlikely as thereβs no chronic infection, hemoptysis, or characteristic imaging findings. |
Spontaneous Pneumothorax | β Subpleural blebs rupture β sudden dyspnea, pleuritic chest pain | No acute onset or pleuritic pain; symptoms are progressive. |
π Flashcards
Stay Hungry, Stay Curious!
Your Brother In This Struggle
Dr. Shoaib Ahmad
psβ¦Just a heads up!
This is just an excerpt from our high-yield Q bank "Excel USMLE Step1: Respiratory System" that we are launching next month InshaAllah.
With this Q-bank, youβll be able to Excel any USMLE Step 1 question on respiratory section without fear of getting a wrong answer using our visual charts and flashcards.
This e-book will feature:
High-yield USMLE Step 1 questions on the respiratory system.
Conceptual clarity for every question to solidify your understanding.
Problem-solving strategies to enhance your test-taking skills.
Flashcards for each question to reinforce learning.
You can pre-order now.
Future editions covering other systems will follow shortly.
Each e-book in the series is priced individually.
Special Offer:
61% off during the pre-order period.
Money-back guarantee if youβre not satisfiedβno questions asked!