- The Step 1 Newsletter
- Posts
- What is the most likely cause of her symptoms?
What is the most likely cause of her symptoms?
🔍 Question
A 42-year-old woman presents with a dry cough and worsening shortness of breath during physical activity. Her medical history includes primary pulmonary hypertension, and she underwent a lung transplant 8 months ago. She reports taking all prescribed transplant medications without any missed doses. A chest X-ray shows postoperative changes consistent with her transplant, but the lung fields are clear. Pulmonary function tests reveal a forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1) at 67% of her best post-transplant value, with her forced vital capacity remaining stable. A lung biopsy shows significant fibrotic obstruction in the terminal bronchioles.
What is the most likely cause of her symptoms?
• A. Acute rejection
• B. Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease
• C. Chronic Transplant rejection
• D. Ischemia-reperfusion injury
• E. Opportunistic infection
• F. Recurrence of pulmonary hypertension

Correct Answer: C. Chronic Transplant Rejection
Chronic transplant rejection = Obliterative Bronchiolitis 🧠
1. Biopsy Clue → Fibrosis = Chronic Process
2. Timeline Clue → 8 Months = Late Post-Transplant Issue
3. Physiology Clue → FEV1 ↓ + Normal FVC = Obstructive Pattern
⚙️
Lung Transplantation
⬇
Immune Response to Allograft
• Chronic low-grade T-cell mediated injury
• Cytokine production ↑ → Activation of fibroblasts 🧠
⬇
Bronchiolar Injury
• Damage to epithelial cells of terminal bronchioles
⬇
Fibrotic Repair
• Excess collagen deposition
• Fibrotic obliteration of small airways 🧠 (Obliterative Bronchiolitis)
⬇
↓ Airflow (Obstructive Pattern)
• FEV1 ↓
• FVC remains unchanged
⬇
Chronic Transplant Rejection Diagnosis
• Hallmark: Fibrotic obstruction of bronchioles on biopsy
Imagine bronchioles as tiny tubes in a pipe system.
• Normal → Air flows freely 🧩
• Fibrotic Injury → The tubes become narrowed & blocked ⚙
• This reduces airflow (↓ FEV1) while total volume (FVC) remains stable.

How to Approach This Question? 🔍
Symptom Onset & Duration ⚙
Chronic timeline (8 months post-transplant) 🧠
⬇
Functional Changes 🧠
• ↓ FEV1 + Normal FVC → Obstructive pattern
• 🧩 Clue: Unchanged lung fields = Nonparenchymal issue
⬇
Biopsy Findings ⚙
• Fibrotic obstruction = Obliterative Bronchiolitis 🧠
⬇
Conclusion 🔍
• Diagnosis: Chronic Transplant Rejection
• Mechanism: Chronic low-grade immune-mediated injury → Fibrosis of small airways
⚖️ Explanation of Other Differentials
Differential | Mechanism ⚙ | Why Incorrect? ⚠ |
---|---|---|
Acute Transplant Rejection | T-cell-mediated injury → Edema + mononuclear infiltrates | Timing: Occurs <6 months. Biopsy shows fibrosis, not edema. |
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) | Smoking/environmental exposure → Airflow limitation | FVC would be proportionally ↓; no fibrosis on biopsy. |
Ischemia-Reperfusion Injury | Free radical injury → Alveolar damage (early post-transplant) | Timing: Immediate post-transplant. CXR would show infiltrates. |
Opportunistic Infection | Immunosuppression → ↑ infection risk, causing infiltrates | CXR is clear; biopsy lacks infectious organisms. |
Recurrence of Pulmonary HTN | ↑ Pulmonary vascular resistance → Right heart failure symptoms | Symptoms reflect vascular issue, not airflow obstruction. |
📝 Flashcards

Click Here to Access All the Flashcards for the Case
Stay Hungry, Stay Curious!
Your Brother In This Struggle
Dr. Shoaib Ahmad

ps…Just a heads up!
This is just an excerpt from the high-yield e-book "Excel USMLE Step 1: Respiratory System" that we are launching next month InshaAllah.
You’ll be able to Excel any USMLE Step 1 question on respiratory section without fear of getting a wrong answer in just 1 week using visual charts and flashcards.
This e-book will feature:
High-yield USMLE Step 1 questions on the respiratory system.
Conceptual clarity for every question to solidify your understanding.
Problem-solving strategies to enhance your test-taking skills.
Flashcards for each question to reinforce learning.
You can pre-order now to secure your copy.
Future editions covering other systems will follow shortly.
Each e-book in the series is priced individually.
Special Offer:
61% off during this pre-order period.
Money-back guarantee if you’re not satisfied—no questions asked!